GRVR ATTORNEYS, INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW SPECIALISTS
  • Home
  • Who we are
    • Client Dedication
    • Our Legal Team
    • Join Our Team
  • Our Practice
    • Customs and Import
    • 301refunds
    • Export
    • Litigation
    • Section 232 and 301 Tariffs
    • Outsource Your Classification
    • CBP Audits
    • Fines, Penalties, Forfeitures, and Seizures
    • Customs Brokers
    • C-TPAT >
      • Mexico C-TPAT >
        • C-TPAT In English
        • Quienes Somos/About Us
    • Foreign-Trade Zones
    • Antidumping and Countervailing Duties
    • Intellectual Property RIghts
    • Foreign Corrupt Practices Act
    • Manifest Confidentiality
    • Contracts and Incoterms
    • False Claims Act and Whistleblower
  • Blog
  • Resources
    • Newsletter >
      • brokermondernization
    • free online import mini-audit
    • free online export mini-audit
  • Calendar and Events
  • Best Customs Broker Exam Course
  • Contact

Can you sue the Federal Government for detaining your shipment?

8/15/2010

0 Comments

 
Picture
The Government has its tentacles in all imports.  This statement is not a criticism (there are many valid and historical justifications for exercising this jurisdiction), but merely recognizes the concrete, cold reality that importers must live with.  The other reality is that government agencies are staffed by (horrors) humans who, for the most part, do a good job, but who sometimes act in a boneheaded manner that costs importers lots of money.  If someone who was not operating under government authority messed with your shipments, you could probably sue them.  Winning and collecting on the lawsuit are whole different matters, but you have a right to sue them.  But what if CBP or FDA seizes your shipment with little justification.  Can you sue?

 Cue the anachronistic legal relic.  The controlling doctrine has its roots in medieval English common law and is called sovereign immunity, or “the king can do no wrong.”  Why our federal courts decided a long time ago to import this precept to our democracy is a tale beyond the scope of this article, but the crux is that you cannot sue the federal government without its permission.  The federal government does not surrender this kind of permission easily, but it did so in 1948 when it enacted the Federal Torts Claims Act.  Now you have permission to sue the US Government, but there are a slew of exceptions.  For importers, the most important one is 28 USC § 2680(c) “(a)ny claim arising in respect of . . . the detention of any goods or merchandise by any officer of customs . . . or any other law-enforcement officer.”  There are, of course, other things that federal agencies do to importers that go beyond detaining goods, and it may be wise to consult with the extensive case law history under the Federal Torts Claims Act and other laws, but it is safe to say that importers have not faired well when they tried to sue the federal government for improper detention of shipments. 

0 Comments

    Oscar Gonzalez

    Principal and a founding member of GRVR Attorneys.

    Archives

    September 2016
    December 2015
    April 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    October 2014
    April 2014
    November 2013
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    September 2011
    July 2011
    May 2011
    January 2011
    December 2010
    September 2010
    August 2010
    July 2010
    June 2010
    May 2010

    Categories

    All
    And Forfeitures
    Bankruptcy
    Border Searches
    Bureau Of Industry And Security
    Classification
    Commodity Jurisdiction
    Compliance
    Country Of Origin
    Court Of International Trade
    C TPAT
    C-TPAT
    Customs Broker Exam
    Customs Brokers
    Export
    Export License
    Export Penalties
    Foreign Corrupt Practices Act
    HTSUS
    Immigration
    Importer Self-Assessment
    Incoterms
    Intellectual Property Rights
    International Sales Contracts
    ITRAC
    Litigation
    NAFTA
    OFAC
    Penalties
    Post-Entry Amendments
    Prior Disclosure
    Redelivery
    Sanctions
    Torts Claims Act

    RSS Feed

Picture
  • Home
  • Who we are
    • Client Dedication
    • Our Legal Team
    • Join Our Team
  • Our Practice
    • Customs and Import
    • 301refunds
    • Export
    • Litigation
    • Section 232 and 301 Tariffs
    • Outsource Your Classification
    • CBP Audits
    • Fines, Penalties, Forfeitures, and Seizures
    • Customs Brokers
    • C-TPAT >
      • Mexico C-TPAT >
        • C-TPAT In English
        • Quienes Somos/About Us
    • Foreign-Trade Zones
    • Antidumping and Countervailing Duties
    • Intellectual Property RIghts
    • Foreign Corrupt Practices Act
    • Manifest Confidentiality
    • Contracts and Incoterms
    • False Claims Act and Whistleblower
  • Blog
  • Resources
    • Newsletter >
      • brokermondernization
    • free online import mini-audit
    • free online export mini-audit
  • Calendar and Events
  • Best Customs Broker Exam Course
  • Contact